← All Lists

Christmas

THE 12 BEST CHRISTMAS HORROR MOVIES OF ALL TIME

Updated Nov 16, 2026

Christmas horror is its own weird little corner of the genre. Killer Santas, evil elves, a whole lot of snow, and families who really should have stayed home this year. Every December I end up rewatching the same handful, so I figured it was time to settle which ones are actually the best.

No gut calls here. Every movie below is ranked by its HOTY List Score, which blends Rotten Tomatoes (critics and audience), Letterboxd, IMDb and Metacritic into one number. If your favorite didn't make it, take it up with the internet.

  1. 1
    Gremlins (1984) poster

    Gremlins (1984)

    77

    Billy gets the weirdest Christmas present in Kingston Falls -- a furry little mogwai named Gizmo that comes with three rules. Naturally, every one of them gets broken, and by Christmas Eve the whole town is crawling with gremlins. Joe Dante directs, Steven Spielberg produces.

    RT Critics 87% · RT Audience 78% · Letterboxd 3.64 · IMDb 7.3 · Metacritic 70 · MC User 7.3

  2. 2
    Inside (2007) poster

    Inside (2007)

    75

    A pregnant widow is spending Christmas Eve alone, the night before she's due to give birth. Then a woman in black (Béatrice Dalle) shows up at her door, and she wants the baby. One of the defining films of the New French Extremity wave, and it's every bit as bloody as that suggests.

    RT Critics 88% · RT Audience 75% · Letterboxd 3.44 · IMDb 6.7

  3. 3
    Black Christmas (1974) poster

    Black Christmas (1974)

    74

    Sorority sisters staying behind over Christmas break start getting obscene phone calls, and one by one they start disappearing. Olivia Hussey and Margot Kidder star. Bob Clark made this nine years before A Christmas Story, and it's widely credited as one of the first true slashers -- four years ahead of Halloween.

    RT Critics 74% · RT Audience 76% · Letterboxd 3.83 · IMDb 7.1

  4. 4
    Rare Exports: A Christmas Tale (2010) poster

    Rare Exports: A Christmas Tale (2010)

    73

    A dig inside a mountain in Finnish Lapland unearths the real Santa Claus, and he's nothing like the mall version. Reindeer get slaughtered, kids start vanishing, and a reindeer herder's young son is the one who figures out what's going on. Directed by Jalmari Helander, who later made Sisu.

    RT Critics 89% · RT Audience 70% · Letterboxd 3.16 · IMDb 6.6 · Metacritic 71 · MC User 6.9

  5. 5
    Better Watch Out (2017) poster

    Better Watch Out (2017)

    70

    A babysitter (Olivia DeJonge) is watching a 12-year-old a few days before Christmas when it starts looking like someone's trying to get into the house. That's all you're getting -- this one runs on a twist. Think Home Alone, if Home Alone went very, very wrong.

    RT Critics 89% · RT Audience 63% · Letterboxd 3.03 · IMDb 6.5 · Metacritic 67 · MC User 6.1

  6. 6
    Night of the Comet (1984) poster

    Night of the Comet (1984)

    67

    A comet buzzes Earth during the holidays and turns almost everyone into red dust. The unlucky ones turn into zombies instead. Two Valley girl sisters in L.A. (Catherine Mary Stewart and Kelli Maroney) are left to deal with it, with a stop at the mall, naturally.

    RT Critics 81% · RT Audience 58% · Letterboxd 3.27 · IMDb 6.3

  7. 7
    The Advent Calendar (2021) poster

    The Advent Calendar (2021)

    67

    A former dancer who now uses a wheelchair gets an antique wooden advent calendar from a friend. Every little door hands out a treat, and every treat does something in real life -- some good, some deadly. The calendar has rules, too, and breaking them isn't an option. A French-Belgian flick that hit the US on Shudder.

    RT Critics 80% · RT Audience 62% · Letterboxd 3.06 · IMDb 6.3

  8. 8
    Anna and the Apocalypse (2018) poster

    Anna and the Apocalypse (2018)

    66

    A zombie outbreak hits a small Scottish town right before Christmas, and high schooler Anna (Ella Hunt) and her friends have to fight their way across it. Oh, and it's a musical. For fans of Shaun of the Dead and High School Musical.

    RT Critics 77% · RT Audience 63% · Letterboxd 3.08 · IMDb 6.1 · Metacritic 63 · MC User 6.3

  9. 9
    Dead End (2003) poster

    Dead End (2003)

    66

    A family driving to the in-laws' on Christmas Eve takes a shortcut down a back road that never seems to end. Then they pick up a mysterious woman in white. Yeah. Ray Wise and Lin Shaye star.

    RT Critics 78% · RT Audience 59% · Letterboxd 3.11 · IMDb 6.4

  10. 10
    The Children (2008) poster

    The Children (2008)

    63

    Two families head to a remote country house for the Christmas holidays. The kids come down with some kind of bug, and then they start trying to kill the adults. A British flick from director Tom Shankland.

    RT Critics 81% · RT Audience 50% · Letterboxd 3.04 · IMDb 5.9

  11. 11
    The Lodge (2019) poster

    The Lodge (2019)

    62

    A soon-to-be stepmom (Riley Keough) gets snowed in at a remote lodge with her fiancé's two kids over Christmas. The kids can't stand her, she's the lone survivor of a religious cult, and things in the house start going wrong. From the directors of Goodnight Mommy.

    RT Critics 75% · RT Audience 51% · Letterboxd 3.10 · IMDb 6.0 · Metacritic 64 · MC User 6.1

  12. 12
    A Christmas Horror Story (2015) poster

    A Christmas Horror Story (2015)

    62

    Four Christmas Eve stories in one small town: a changeling, a family hunted by Krampus, teens poking around a haunted school, and Santa fighting off his elves after they turn into zombies. William Shatner ties it all together as the town's radio DJ.

    RT Critics 83% · RT Audience 51% · Letterboxd 2.74 · IMDb 5.8

Just missed the cut: Krampus (2015) at 59.

How this list is ranked

Each film gets a HOTY List Score out of 100. Half of it is the average of the Rotten Tomatoes critic and audience scores. The other half is the average of Letterboxd, IMDb and Metacritic (critic and user), converted to a 100-point scale. It's the same Mainstream Sites math behind the Rot Score, minus the genre-site and Satan's Boardroom buckets, which don't cover older films. Scores as of Nov 16, 2026.